Skip to content
← Academia

Auditing a Packaging LCA: Three Input Errors That Flattered a Soap Redesign

Life cycle assessment · November 2026COLUMBIA MS
77%Less non-renewable energy per bar
~610 GJSaved a year
3Input errors found
COURSETheory and Practice of Life Cycle Assessment · SUMA PS5021
PROGRAMM.S. in Sustainability Management, Columbia University
COMPLETEDNovember 2026
AUTHOREmporia Meng
THE BRIEF

The brief asked each student to perform a formal critical review of a professional life cycle assessment, the exercise ISO 14044 reserves for an independent third party: obtain the model and its source documents, verify every material claim, and render a judgment on whether the study’s conclusions deserve confidence. The study under review, supplied as a non-public course file, was a packaging LCA prepared for a bar soap brand weighing a redesigned paper wrap against its original paperboard carton, which is why this page confines itself to findings.

METHOD

The review worked parameter by parameter through the GaBi model. Inputs were checked against the client’s specification, and every per-bar mass was rebuilt by hand from the parameter file and reconciled against the software’s totals. That discipline cleared the arithmetic inside the model and directed the scrutiny where it belonged, at the inputs feeding it.

FINDINGS

The headline energy result held up under review. Switching from the carton to the paper wrap reduces non-renewable primary energy by 77% per bar, roughly 610 GJ a year at the brand’s estimated volume and closer to 810 GJ once the larger bar size is counted. The review also derived a carbon intensity per kilogram of packaging for the redesign, a benchmark the brand can track against future changes.

The audit nonetheless isolated three material input errors behind the clean printout: a bundle film entered at the wrong packaging level, a carton modeled as virgin board where the client’s own specification says recycled, and a manufacturing step absent from the new design’s wrap. Each error flattered the redesign, and none is visible from the software’s output alone.

RECOMMENDATION

The closing recommendation is a one-page reconciliation table at the front of every report, listing each model parameter beside the client source figure it came from. All three errors become conspicuous the moment the two columns sit side by side, and every number becomes something a sustainability manager can verify in minutes.

Every number was trusted only once the software printout, the parameter file and the client’s slides agreed. The arithmetic inside the model was sound. The problems were in what was fed to it, and each one made the new design look better than it is.

Full version available upon request.

All case studies →
Non-renewable primary energy per bar

Old pack: cartonbaseline

Redesign: paper wrap77% less

Roughly 610 GJ a year at the brand’s estimated volume, closer to 810 GJ once the larger bar is counted.

NEXTReading Apple’s Carbon Claims: A Review of the MacBook Neo Environmental Report