Glass Bottle vs Aluminum Can: A Life Cycle Assessment of Pepsi Packaging in China
Life cycle assessment · October 2026COLUMBIA MS| COURSE | Life Cycle Assessment · SUMAPS 5021 |
|---|---|
| PROGRAM | M.S. in Sustainability Management, Columbia University |
| COMPLETED | October 2026 |
| AUTHOR | Emporia Meng |
The brief asked for a complete cradle to grave life cycle assessment built from the inventory up: define a functional unit, construct the model across every life stage, and defend the result under uncertainty. The comparison chosen was two Pepsi packaging formats sold in China, a reusable glass bottle against an aluminum can.
METHOD
The functional unit is one 201 ml reusable glass bottle of regular Pepsi set against one 302 ml aluminum can of the same product, modeled across eight life cycle stages from ingredients and packaging through bottling, distribution, retail, use and end of life. Emission factors come from Ecoinvent with IPCC GWP values on a 100 year horizon, recycling is handled through the recycled content method for both materials, and the model claims no credit for offsets or biogenic carbon.
RESULTS
The bottle carries a footprint of 145.8 g CO2e and the can 383.9 g, both cradle to grave. Normalized per milliliter, the bottle comes in roughly 43% lower. Packaging dominates both systems, at 45% of the bottle’s footprint and 86% of the can’s.
FINDINGS
The assessment culminates in a finding that confounds every first intuition: the bottle’s 2.3 gram single use aluminum lid out-emits the 380 gram glass bottle it caps, because the bottle circulates through roughly 53 reuse cycles while a fresh lid accompanies every trip. Reuse distributes the glass across dozens of servings, and the one component denied that treatment quietly becomes the largest line in the inventory.
SENSITIVITY
The gap withstands stress testing. Perturbing the three most uncertain inputs, the primary aluminum emission factor, bottles per pallet and outbound transport distance, holds the bottle’s advantage between 0.34 and 0.49 g CO2e per milliliter, and the ranking never inverts. The implication for packaging decisions is that reuse systems outperform material swaps in this model, and a brand would gain more from redesigning or recovering the lid than from most changes to the bottle itself.
The 2.3 gram aluminum lid out-emits the 380 gram glass bottle it caps. The bottle is reused about 53 times, and a fresh lid goes on every trip.
Full version available upon request.
Packaging alone accounts for 45% of the bottle’s total and 86% of the can’s.
- Cradle to grave, stages S1 to S8
- Ecoinvent emission factors, IPCC GWPs on a 100 year horizon
- Recycled content method for glass and aluminum
- No offsets, no biogenic carbon credit
- Sensitivity tested on the three most uncertain inputs