Skip to content
← Academia

Why Circularity Stalls at JFK: Airport Interiors and the TWA Hotel

Strategy & circularity · May 2026COLUMBIA MS
COURSECircular Economy · PS5470
PROGRAMM.S. in Sustainability Management, Columbia University
COMPLETEDMay 2026
AUTHORSDanna Echevarria, Emporia Meng and Jett Elin
THE BRIEF

The brief asked each team to diagnose why circularity stalls in a real system and to design an intervention with a credible path to adoption. The system chosen was airport interiors at JFK and the TWA Hotel.

BACKGROUND

Construction accounts for 42% of global CO2 emissions and 30 to 40% of global solid waste, and JFK concentrates that flow into a single campus, moving 62.6 million passengers a year through terminals under near-continuous renovation. The underlying mismatch is one of clocks: structures endure for roughly 60 years while interior partitions are exchanged at around 15, finishes and furniture at around 8, and retail fit-outs at around 5, with replacement triggered by wear or a rebrand rather than failure.

DIAGNOSIS

The diagnosis is systemic rather than technical. Aviation, security, retail, food service and hospitality operate in parallel, and every actor optimizes for something defensible, whether operational stability, schedule reliability, a regular refresh, speed of installation or throughput. None of those priorities points toward material recovery, assemblies are glued and fixed because they are faster to approve, and recovered material has no system to enter. Disposal persists as the default.

PROPOSAL

The proposed intervention is design for disassembly written into the contract from day one: interiors specified to come apart cleanly, components recovered, cataloged with barcodes and reused inside the airport or in the wider New York construction market, with the installing crews contractually responsible for the eventual disassembly. The rollout pilots on retail counters and TWA Hotel guest room refresh cycles before extending to seating areas and gate hubs.

BUSINESS CASE

The commercial case rests on downtime, the expensive commodity at an airport. Gensler places modular delivery at 65% faster than conventional construction, and Corgan documents $500 million saved by airlines at Atlanta’s Hartsfield-Jackson, where modular execution minimized gate closures. Local Law 97 and the 2025 NYC Energy Code supply the policy tailwind, and the same structural lesson transfers to any organization where the person specifying a material is never the person who pays to remove it.

JFK Airport and the TWA Hotel illustrate how circularity challenges are not driven by a lack of solutions, but by systemic patterns that prioritize speed, convenience, and short-term performance over long-term material retention. Interiors cycle through repeated installation and replacement, while structural systems remain intact, creating a persistent gap between use and value. Without intervention at the system level, this pattern continues to reinforce itself, making disposal the default rather than recovery.

Full version available upon request.

All case studies →
Replacement clocks inside one building

Building structure~60 years

Interior partitions~15 years

Finishes & furniture~8 years

Retail fit-outs~5 years

Interiors cycle many times inside one structure’s life, and replacement is triggered by wear or a rebrand rather than failure.

NEXTIs the Energy Transition Priced In? A Valuation Memo on GE Vernova